Senior managers at Forest Enterprise have at last responded. At the second of two meetings, FDF was told that if the community does not want off road driving, then it will be removed from Kirkton Wood/ Durris Forest. The first meeting took place with the Chief Executive of Forest Enterprise, Dr Bob McIntosh, at the end of November, to evaluate the experience of the 12 month trial. In January, Dr Hugh Insley, Director for North Scotland Territory, announced the new strategy.
FDF was asked to go back to its members and ascertain their views. In close consultation with Forest Enterprise, a ballot was held, using precisely the questions that had been posed by Dr Insley. Members voted convincingly and decisively to stop off road driving in Kirkton Wood/Durris Forest. Two affiliated organisations voted to stop off road driving. Members also agreed that they wished FDF to help in the process of removal of the project.
Now FDF has asked Forest Enterprise to implement its promises, and to remove off road driving from Durris Forest and Kirkton Wood.
SNH report ignored
Scottish Natural Heritage wrote a highly critical advice to the Council, in which it recommended better environmental management and monitoring, and was concerned about conflict with recreational users. In its haste to put the application before Committee in December, the Planning Department had not waited for the SNH advice before preparing its report.
However, following deferral for a site visit in December, the revised report discouraged adoption of the central SNH recommendation of ‘a Section 75 Agreement to regulate the implementation and management of the proposal as recommended in our letter of 10 February 1999, on the grounds that it was ‘too onerous a requirement’.
We should all be concerned that the recommendations of SNH as statutory consultee should be treated in such a cavalier manner. And also that the management of the environment should be so disregarded.
High Farce in Council
At its January meeting, the Kincardine & Mearns Area
Committee met to decide the application for off road driving in perpetuity in
Kirkton Wood / Durris Forest. The members of the Committee had visited the
forest for a site inspection in December, and some of the members were appalled
by the environmental impact that they saw.
Other councillors concluded that because they saw no
recreational users, the forest was not much used for this purpose! Councillor
Wallace had requested that FDF members were not in the forest on that day!
However LRHE did not stay away, and off-roaders were observed playing in the
quarry.
At the Area Committee meeting, the Community Council and FDF
delivered a spirited critique of the trial of off road driving. During this
presentation, reference was made to the agreement with Forest Enterprise (see
above). The Council did not invite Kevin Peace, the local Forest
Enterprise manager, to explain the agreement – even though he was present in
the room!
The Council meeting ended in true farce. Having discussed a variety of side issues with some interest, the Councillors from Stonehaven and the Mearns voted :
· not to defer the application until Forest Enterprise had sorted out a new site;
· not to include a Section 75 Management Agreement;
· to approve the application as proposed.
So now we have a planning consent for off road driving in perpetuity in Kirkton Wood/Durris Forest - which Forest Enterprise has said it will not permit!
Our thanks to Councillors who tried to introduce some sanity into the process: Mhairi Nash who moved the rejection of the application, seconded by Anne Tunstall; Harrison McLean who moved the postponement, seconded by Sandy Wallace.
Please
renew your membership by 1st April 2001.
Your
membership is our strength!
FDF
Alternative Plan
On
12th October, FDF submitted to Aberdeenshire Council a plan
for a network of recreational and educational trails in the Durris Forests for
different users. The plan arises from the public meeting in Kirkton Hall on 2nd
October 2000.
·
In Clune Wood it is proposed
to improve access to the Bronze Age stone circle and cairns and to provide
information about them.
·
A historical and environmental
trial is proposed for Kirkton Wood.
·
In Durris Forest, there are
ambitious plans to develop cycle and walking trails to enable people to explore
parts of the forest away from the main network of forest roads.
·
Story Trail
& Elsick Mounth see below.
The
Elsick Mounth path is now waymarked from the Warren Wood entrance on Skye
Brae to the Rickarton Estate boundary, through partnership with Forest
Enterprise.
The
trail is appropriate for all users when on forest roads; on some sections it is
inappropriate for horses and cycles - with obvious alternative routes.
Waymarking
and improvement works on the Rickarton Estate are to be carried out in the next
month through partnership with Aberdeenshire Council.
Stonehaven
Ramblers have agreed to work with FDF on the extension of the route to
Stonehaven.
A
route map will be developed in 2001.
Deeside
Storytellers have invited us to work
with them to develop a story trail in the woods. We will seek funding in
partnership, and plan to develop the story trail with local children. Anyone who
would like to help this innovative project should contact Mandy Catto on 811904,
or Mark Hagger on 811328
See
the FDF website for the latest about Durris Forest, our alternative plan,
photographs of environmental impact of off road driving:
www.friendsofdurrisforests.co.uk
Check out the activities planned for
2001 and all the latest news.
Sat 24 Mar: Path-clearing & tree-planting day
Sat 26 May: Elsick Mounth walk Drumoak to Stonehaven Summer: Story Trail project
Sun 14 Oct: Seed
gathering Sunday / Autumn Gold walk
Nov: Tree planting in National Tree Week
The FDF Committee has been busy implementing the ballot in January. Meantime a group is working on the Co-Management Agreement, in order to gain full partnership with Forest Enterprise in the management of the forests. Another group is working on trail development. If you have any suggestions, or would like to contribute to one of the working groups, please contact any committee member. ((: 01330-…)
John Coyne (844787) Philip Dean (811308)
Maureen
Gibson (811396)Paulette Gould (811625)
Mark
Hagger (811328)
Mike Potter (811725)
Sophie
Trafford (811488) James White (811756)
David
Felstead (811884)(Membership Officer)
Kevin
Peace (844625)(Forest Enterprise manager)
Almost
one fifth of Durris Forest has been clear felled in the past few months. Large
logs of Sitka and some larch and pine have been lorried out to the timber mills
for processing. Other timber of lesser quality has been chipped directly in the
forest.
Users
are asked to avoid areas where timber operations are taking place, for safety
reasons. The forest roads are suffering under the heavy use. FDF is
talking with Forest Enterprise to ensure that the whole forest will be available
for recreation use as soon as possible.
Maps
at www.old-maps.co.uk
shows how the forest looked in the 19th century. Pitcowdens and
Hillhead were still being farmed. Cairn-mon-Earn and Mundernal were not yet
forested, presumably being open hillside and grouse moor in those days.